Similar Posts


  1. Peeps are still my favorite Easter treat! Thanks for sharing how we can make our own. I saw your post over at Merry Monday Link Party.

    1. Christene Holder says:

      Hi there! Thanks for stopping by! Yes, I feel like nothing says Easter treat like a Peep.


      1. Can corn syrup be substituted with Agave Syrup? Trying to make these corn syrup free. Please help! Thank you!

        1. Hi Donna,

          I did not try that, but I have heard that agave can be a good corn syrup substitute. Let me know if the consistency turns out similar.

          >> Christene

  2. Thanks for sharing this on Merry Monday! As you noticed, you are my featured pick for this week’s party. I hope you come and link up again with us! 🙂

    1. Christene Holder says:

      Thanks Marie! I’m so glad I was your pick – you made my day!
      I love all the inspiration for the Merry Monday party, definitely linking up again.

  3. I love Peeps and I love homemade marshmallows, never thought to put them in a shaped mold, but you better believe I will be doing this a lot now 🙂 Thanks! Pinned.

    1. Christene Holder says:

      Thanks for the pin Kati! There are tons of different molds out there too so you could make these for lots of different occasions. Just use lots of non-stick spray 🙂

  4. Thanks so much for sharing this recipe. I bought the PEEPS mold last year but never go around to making them. They look great!

    1. Christene Holder says:

      Thanks Sherry! At least you have the mold now for next year 🙂 or even just spring bunnies (not necessarily Easter)
      >> Christene

  5. Katharine says:

    I just made these, they’re currently sitting for the 2 hrs. Mine was very thick and hard to spread in the bunny molds. Any suggrestion?

    1. Hmm… you may have overwhipped them and therefore made them a little too stiff. Maybe mix for slightly less time next time to get a less thick texture

  6. How long do they last after making and how do you store them?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *